Every third Monday in February, our government sets asides a day we call President’s Day, to honor those who have held the office of President of the United States.  While as a general rule, I do not get terribly excited about this particular Federal holiday, I have had a special interest in the history of the American presidency since I was kid.  In fact, it was sometime in grade school that I memorized the list of the Presidents, and can still recite all forty-three occupants in order along with the dates that served.  (Trivia question: Did you know that while Barack Obama is the 44th President of the United States, there have only been 43 occupants?  Do you know why?  I won’t answer this question in blog, but just leave the question for your consideration).

Several months ago, I stumbled across this short video documenting all the presidents who had been on portrayed on film.  Not all of the American Presidents have had actors play them, but many of the former occupants of the White House have been played by multiple famous actors in different films.  And so, in honor of the good, the bad and the ugly who have played the famous and infamous of the American Presidency, I thought for a short blog, I would present this short video along with a list of my favorite portrayals of American Presidents in film.

First, let me say a word about the film itself.  As I mentioned, not every single President has been portrayed in films, and I am not familiar with some of clips that were chosen here.  And there are a few actors that were omitted from this film that I would have included, and other clips I would have excluded.  Nonetheless, it does provide a decent overview of actors who have played different presidents in film.

Second, let me say word about my list.  I chose every single actor, not based on the quality of the film, but on what I perceived as the individual actor’s attempt to portray the particular president in which they were cast.  Some of the films listed here were fairly accurate historically while others were based more on historical myth than historical facts.  Those films made great films, but were better propaganda pieces than true historical presentations.  So please do not think that any particular film on my list has my blessing as an historian.  Some of them really pretty loose with the facts.    Nonetheless, based on my knowledge of those particular presidents, I thought the actors did a good job at either capturing the spirit of the man or his particular role in history.  And that was my primary criterion for the list.  And so without further explanation, here is my list of favorite Presidential Actors and a short history of the American Presidency in Film:

Top Actors for American Presidents:

1. Barry Bostwick (George Washington in CBS’s mini-series, George Washington (1984), and its sequel, George Washington II: The Forging of a Nation (1986)).

2. Paul Giamatti (John Adams in HBO’s mini-series based on David McCullough’s biography, John Adams (2008)).

3. Anthony Hopkins (John Quincy Adams in Steven Spielberg’s film, Amistad (1997)).

4. Charlton Heston (Andrew Jackson in the films, The President Lady (1953), and The Buccaneer  (1958)).

5. Sam Waterson (Abraham Lincoln in the film adaption of Gore Vidal’s book, Lincoln (1988)), and Daniel Day-Lewis (in the Steven Spielberg film, Lincoln (2012)).

6. Brian Keith (Theodore Roosevelt in John Milius’ film, The Wind and the Lion (1975)) and Tom Berenger (playing Roosevelt during the Spanish-American War in TNT’s mini-series, Rough Riders (1997)).

7. Ralph Bellamy (Franklin D. Roosevelt in Herman Wouk’s The Winds of War (1983), and War and Remembrance (1988)), and Kenneth Branagh (in the 2005 film, Warm Springs, which tells the story of Roosevelt’s pre-presidential struggle with polio.)

8. Martin Sheen (John F. Kennedy in NBC’s mini-series, Kennedy (1983)), and Bruce Greenwood (as President Kennedy during the Cuban Missile Crisis in the film, Thirteen Days (2000)).

9. James Brolin (Ronald Reagan in the mini-series, The Reagans (2003)).

10. Dennis Quaid (Bill Clinton in the BBC/HBO film, That Special Relationship (2010)).